I you don't have your heart set on one of those two consider the I river H320 or H340. They have built in tuners and are very nice. I picked the H320 over the IPod. Check out this link for a good reference on the I-River products. Go to the forums and read up.
http://misticriver.net/ By the way the also have a fm tuner
(Message edited by sbt3 on June 03, 2005)