Jamming big toe - bindings fit great, toe buckling maybe?

So I bought a new Ronix One setup at the beginning of this year. Heat molded the bindings twice and felt like these things were fitting perfectly. Then I jammed/buckled my big toe about 3 weeks ago attempting a scarecrow landing to far on my heels obviously. Felt like I broke it, couldn’t even move it. Taped up the toe and was riding a few days later. Seemed like things were fine until this past weekend I definitely did it again and kept riding. I know I’m probably just reinjuring it but I can’t stop riding. I can tape up the toe good and it helps but this really has me thinking of going back to open toe boots like the Kai’s. My salesman said we should try packing the right foot binding out so my toe has a tad more room and maybe doesn’t buckle. I’m a size 10.5-11 shoe and my one’s are size 10. I really feel that they fit perfectly. At this point I just think open toe will eliminate any more toe problems. Guess I’m just looking for some feedback on whether more room in the toes could help? I realize landing better would help too but sometimes you don’t always do a trick completely right.