The fish has some of the softest landings ever. As soon as I get a little more moola in the bank, I'm gonna switch from my 136 Temet to a 129 Fish. I never really liked the Temet. Too rolly from toe to heelside edge. I will agree that the Fish is a super slow board, but the great thing is it can get away with it. The board holds such a nice edge up the wake and is so explosive that you don't need a super hard aggressive cut to get it to work for you.
Jamie, I'm about 5'9" 195 lbs and liked the 129 Fish. You should probably go with the next size down.