There was the Kinetic debate with some good information from Interstate and a few others. search "Kinetic" to find it.
My point is that optimas are pretty expensive. Are you getting $150 worth of battery? Maybe. But like Karl said, good insurance in a boat. I've never had a battery explode so I guess can't appreciate one that won't.
i run two blue tops and 2 6vt cart batts. The cart batts give me 225 amp hrs of batter reserve that i have dedicated to powering amps. i would have to buy at least 4 optimas to get the same capacity. at $155 each... eh, I don't think so. There are other things i would rather throw my money at.
But I still own 2 blue tops.
I've replaced them once, optima wouldn't help. I guess that's my other problem with them. do a search there's a ton of info on batts on here.