boat buddy problem

Went to load the boat up last night and the boat buddy didn't work quite right. The pin snapped through as it was suppose to, but it didn't snap into the opposite hole. It missed and is actually too far back (toward the boat, not the truck). I'm thinking the only way this could happen is if the pin was bent? I don't see anything that can be adjusted to compensate for this? Any ideas? Also, without doing any searching, anyone have an estimate how much a new boat buddy is if I needed one? Thanks.