Good summary Dave. I sure hope you are happy with the new ride!
http://www.wakesiderides.com/forums/ may also be a helpful place to get some info.
You will be able to get a nice wake out of both boats… Depends how much room you need in the boat and if you want to deal with extra ballast or not.
I have an 04 VLX and when behind my friends 05…. It’s HUGE inside! I can’t imagine why you would need more room inside the boat! Especially with the rear ballast being under the floor.
The newer LSV I rode behind was not fully loaded (gas too) and the water was not the best that day…. But yes it is a bit wider than the VLX.
I say VLX.
Not sure the 8.1 would be my first choice of engines based on current gas prices either.