I hate to admit it, by Loc over at WO.com did a good job of summarizing options for surf style boards, for an individual your general size, note his comment at the end:
"In order by recommendation:
#1) Outlaw (LARGE)
#2) IS Swallow
#3) IS Red Woody / IS Blue Lake
#4) Composite-X 5.0
#5) TX Fast Fish
There's another list for skim style & customs but out of the box - that's the best of the best."
The thread is
here