Superglue is a cynoacrylate so it is brittle and not suitable for plastic to metal. Gorilla Glue or some other urethane will work the best. Many contact cements are also good. They can be removed easier than the urethanes. The 3M weatherstripping adhesive should be great.
Like Sam said, the prep is important. Clean old glue, slightly rough the surfaces, use alcohol to remove any oils or residue.