Wow...not everday you see someone from NWI on here. Your name sounds familiar for some reason though...hmmm
I used to live on Cedar Lake, and you're right, it gets to be a madhouse out there later in the day. There's about a dozen of us who live in Lakes of the Four Seasons and we all mostly ride out there because the conditions are better.
I know a few people who ride regularily on Cedar Lake and I can pass along your email address to them if they are ever looking for a third or to get out on someone elses boat.
Anyway, hit me up with your email address and I'll pass it along. Maybe try and get you a pull out by us where you can get some flat water. email@example.com