WakeWorld (http://www.wakeworld.com/forum/index.php)
-   Archive through December 15, 2008 (http://www.wakeworld.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=655460)
-   -   X1 vs X2..... (http://www.wakeworld.com/forum/showthread.php?t=649402)

dirwoody 12-05-2008 7:00 AM

I'm stuck between 2 boats, 1 will come home with me. Assume both have the same options: <BR> <BR>'08 X1, brand new, never touched the water - Local <BR> VS. <BR>'07 X2, 300 hrs, used in a dealership's wake school, they are willing to give full factory warranty as if it has 0 hrs. - 10 hrs down the road <BR> <BR>I can't decide

malibuboats4 12-05-2008 7:00 AM

08 x1

laptom 12-05-2008 8:27 AM

08 X1

dirwoody 12-05-2008 8:43 AM

That's the way I've been leaning, just thought I would get some outside opinions <BR> <BR>Thanks!

eaglejackson 12-05-2008 8:49 AM

X1. Awesome wake. Which engine do they both have? Hopefully the X1 has the MCX. <BR> <BR>(Message edited by eaglejackson on December 05, 2008)

lifetimewarranty 12-05-2008 9:15 AM

X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1X1 <BR> <BR>I'm just sayin...

gti2lo 12-05-2008 9:41 AM

300 hours is "barely" broken in.. they should be giving you a nice price beak on the X-2 to make it worth while. <BR> <BR>There is alot more room in the X-2 compared to the X-1. <BR> <BR> <BR>X-1 is a great boat.. great for skiiing too

dizzyj 12-05-2008 9:44 AM

X1 is my favorite boat. That said, the x2 will probably have an easier resale.

dirwoody 12-05-2008 9:47 AM

Yep, both have the MCX. <BR>The price break is definately good on the 2, but price isn't the issue

eas 12-05-2008 11:39 AM

If "price isn't the issue"....then that begs the question: "what is the issue?" <BR> <BR>if comfort, storage, and room to spread out with a big crew are the issues --> X2 <BR> <BR>if pure wake machine is the issue --> X1 <BR> <BR>as stated above, I definitely wouldn't let 300hrs make my decision.

stephan 12-05-2008 11:51 AM

X1 simply for wake quality. The X2 is a nice boatwith loads of space but <u><b>IMO</b></u> does not have the wake of the X1.

libertylake 12-05-2008 12:16 PM

I have owned both and now in an X15 which I feel offers the best of both worlds. The X1 has a better wakeboard wake, but not the surf wake of the X2. So it really depends on what your going to use if for. Skiing/boarding/small crew go X1, Boarding/Surfing larger crew go X2. If you want the best of all three go X15 with the plate.

dirwoody 12-05-2008 1:12 PM

Smaller crew, but will use it for both boarding and surfing. Probably more boarding though. <BR> <BR>Eric - The hours and the whole local thing are the issues with the X2. My local dealer treats us extremely well.

jarrod 12-05-2008 1:16 PM

If you're all about Wakeboarding, get the X1.

romes 12-05-2008 1:31 PM

X1...with a few k's of ballast is one of the best wake ALL TIME...get the plate option, it will allow you to get more weight in there and plane out quicker, saves a lot of gas. <BR> <BR>we ran a plate in the x15 all summer and it works AWESOME.

bob_l 12-05-2008 1:38 PM

I own a 07 X1 and love it as it fits MY needs to a T. If you frequently have a large crew, the X1 might disappoint as it will get cramped with over 6 people. You cant beat the wake on the X1 and it skis nice. As for the MCX vs. RTP comment, my buddy has the MCX and I have the RTP and I have been completely satisfied with the RTP and have never been looking for more power. As for resale of X2, I would think a new X1 would resell better with lower hours than a 300 hour X2 and with this economy, I would also think the X1 would be a better value but that is my $0.02. <BR> <BR>The good news is you cant go wrong with either. Good luck!

wakesurf_ohio 12-05-2008 2:05 PM

The x1 surf wake can get the job done.. never ridden on an x2 to compare though <BR><img src="http://www.wakeworld.com/MB/Discus/messages/65921/649497.jpg" alt="Upload">

eas 12-05-2008 2:58 PM

yea...I forgot to mention that the 10 hour drive would turn me off a little for the same money....especially if your local dealer is that great to work with. <BR> <BR>I will say that I bought and sold my last boat as long distance deals, and the buying didn't go nearly as smooth as the selling but I don't think either went that bad. in the end, it'll depend on which boat you want more. for me...it would be X1 all the way....of course, I'm not a very popular guy and my crew size reflects that. good luck!

eaglejackson 12-05-2008 3:36 PM

If you're wakeboarding, I'm not sure you want more than 4-5 in the boat anyways. Otherwise it's a LONG time between pulls. <BR> <BR>X2 is a better package (more space, more comfort) and would be a better boat except for one thing -- the X1 wake ROCKS and for boarding is way better. <BR> <BR>My dealer says the X2 surf wake is way better than the X1's. I haven't tried it, though, and find the X1 surf wake just fine.

bwood 12-05-2008 3:39 PM

Jr, what's the plate option you are talking about? I have a 06 X1 and would like to hear more about it.

dlamont 12-06-2008 1:41 PM

X1 for wakeboarding. X2 for multipurpose. <BR>Support your local dealer.

chqwakeboarder 12-06-2008 8:19 PM

Woody, <BR>I believe that jr made a mistake. I do not believe that you can get a factory plate on an X1. He said he used one on his X15 and just assumed that you can get one on an X1.

bwood 12-07-2008 4:00 AM

I'v done some searching and havn't found anyone that has a wake plate on a X1.

gti2lo 12-07-2008 7:46 AM

I don't think you need one... wake gets pretty flat >32mph

joe_crawley 12-07-2008 10:12 AM


njskier 12-07-2008 2:31 PM

Hard to do better than the X-1 with an MCX, nice find! Nothing like a brand new boat with zero hours. <BR>I'd be afraid of a 300-hour boat used at a wake school, unless it was well cared for. <BR> <BR>My vote................X-1! <BR> <BR> <img src="http://www.wakeworld.com/MB/Discus/messages/65921/650042.jpg" alt="Upload">

tampawake 12-07-2008 6:05 PM

Most wake schools have to follow a very regimented maintenance schedule. Typically these are great finds because you get full warranty. Make sure the engine warranty does not have an hour limit because most manufacturers don't warranty the engine that is done by indmar or pcm I believe. Now the hull is different and acc are handled by manufacturer.

sanger 12-07-2008 7:26 PM

The ones I've seen from schools (and pro riders) have a number of scuffs and scratches on the fiberglass and upholstery. Those are obvious things you would see on inspection. On the mechanical side a computer scan can tell you a lot about how the engine has been operated. Maintenance records will show time intervals between service. I have a X1 and really like it but I think the X2 line is the number one selling boat for MC. Tough call!

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 5:24 PM.